One of my sisters sent me a packet of information about a distant relative – Cousin Julius – a Civil War veteran whose 102nd birthday was celebrated in Life Magazine. Part of the package included a story written by my father. I transcribed the story, intending to print it and send it to my siblings. Well, somehow the writing program didn’t recognize my printer. So, here is the story. As written by my father nearly 75 years ago – along with all his little misspellings and quirks that made the story uniquely his…
MacPheerson and the Smiling Nude
“Whenever I visit you in Norfolk there are always two things of which I can be sure: First, you like me as a friend but do not wish to put any money in my venture. Next, there will be an ad in the Sunday paper which will ask for information concerning Doris Batker.”
“Right on both counts.”
“Now you insist on the reason that you will not back me is that you think that my ideas are good in theory but will not be good in practice. The reason for mentioning Miss Batker is to disprove your ideas of me. Look at this ad.”
Reward: For information of the whereabouts of
Doris Batker who was last seen boarding a train
for Washington 15 March 1943. At the time she
was wearing a mink coat and had but one small,
leather bag with her. She is blond, has a star-shaped
scar on the left side of her face, and should be now
twenty-six years old.
No other information is known.
Contact J.M. Mason, Selden arcade, Norfolk for the
reward.
“I have seen the ad; I do not need to read it again.”
“Well, Tom, here are my ideas on the subject. Miss Batker is of no relation to Mason. He is a well known bachelor and so would hardly be a foster parent. He is the best and most expensive lawyer in town. The cost of employing Mason, together with the mink coat, tells us that more than the girl’s personal safety is involved. All the facts tell us someone other than Miss Batker is to gain, else there would not be this long ad each Sunday.”
“Mac, you have done nothing but tell me what is obvious. What you do not know is that the girl is my cousin. The exact reason for wishing to find her is this: Soon after Doris vanished an uncle left a will which divides his estate among Doris, my mother, and me. The will is so worded that the money will be in the form of trusts, but the money from the trusts will go to certain charities until Doris is found or is proven to be dead; she cannot be declared dead.”
“And so you still offer the reward.”
“Not I; mother is the one offering the reward. My interest in the case ended when Doris’s parents were killed in an auto crash. But all of this puts us back where we started: you are rather good with theory, even if the theory is a well known one.”
Tom stood up.
“Would you care to see a copy of the picture which Pinkerton’s used while trying to find the girl? See how the scar shows there by her eye.”
MacPheerson studied the photo of the girl for a while before he spoke. “Tom, if I were to find the girl, say within a month, would you be willing to add enough money to the reward, but in the form of a loan, to put my venture into action?”
“Only to say no more of the loan if you do not find the girl.”
“Agreed.”
Three weeks later, Tom opened a thick envelope that had come in the morning mail. He found it to be the following report from MacPherson:
To Tom Ashman, Report on Doris Batker.
The face in the picture of Doris that you showed me was a face I had seen before. Three days before, my brother-in-law had, as a joke, given me a photo of a sexy nude. The face of the nude was that of Doris. The question that presented itself was one of tracing the photograph to the model.
My brother-in-law told me that he had gotten the photo at a shop on Madison Avenue in Chicago. So I took the next plane. The keeper of the designated shop refused to admit that he had sold this or any other photograph of a nude. He was not open to bribery, so I threatened to call for intervention by the police if he did not wish to aid me. Just how I should have gotten the police to do something was not clear to me; but it was not clear to the shop-keeper, either. Quickly he told me that the photo had come from an establishment on the south side.
When I gave the address to my cab driver, he told me to wait while he made a phone call. He returned and we were off on a brief but hazardous ride across town. The number that the shop-keeper had given me turned out to be over a bar; the sign on the door said that it was a photographic studio. My driver followed me in like a faithful dog. At the top of the steps two large and unshaven men grabbed me by the arms and told me to come with them; there was nothing else that I could have done. Two other gentlemen cared for my faithful dog.
We were taken into one of the nicest offices that I had ever seen. Every object was expensive and well chosen. From the far side of a desk we were viewed by a well dressed Italian of about forty.
“The boys and I found out you were on the way to see us. Now why?”
While I told him that I wished to find Doris, my two escorts emptied my pockets and put what they found in front of the Italian. It was more than obvious that he did not believe a word I was saying.
“The boys and I do not wish to get rough; tell me who sent you.” His voice was not rough, but it was one of authority. His lighting a cigarette was the signal for one of my escorts to slap me soundly on the left side of my face. Till then I had thought of such a blow as being a sort of token resistance offered by a woman. I hope that they never find what a deadly weapon they have. “Who sent you?” My lack of what he considered a proper reply was rewarded by another blow in the face, but this time with a closed fist.
This sort of thing could have gone on for a long while but I thought it was time to use my head and not let it be used. “Let’s stop all this nonsense, and I will give it to you straight,” I said picking myself up from the floor. The Italian offered me a chair near the center of the room and I gladly took it. “Where is my driver?” I asked.
“The boys took him into the next room. But remember this: from now on I ask the questions. You had best be full of the proper answers.”
“If you do not believe that there is a Doris Batker, send one of your lads out for a Norfolk paper; there should still be one in the stands. And if you do not believe that I am trying to find her, you may phone Tom Ashman at my expense.”
“You are doing nothing but playing for time. It may be that you enjoy being knocked in the face. So, if you do not…”
At this point the place was alive with police. They took one look at my battered face and muttered something about assault while they put the cuffs on the Italian and his boys. “If those lads are sent to gaol,” thought I, “I should never find more information of Doris.” So I spoke up: “Officers, you have the entire thing wrong. You would never arrest a mother for spanking a naughty child, would you? Well, these gentlemen are of the opinion that I am not a very good in-law, and they are right. As long as we were not disturbing the peace, and as long as I don’t mind, let us drop the matter. What do you say?”[1]
Their leader said that if I did not press charges he could not take them to the station; he also said he thought I was a fool for not doing so. He gathered his men and left.
“Look,” I said to the Italian when the last of the police left the room, “I could have gotten out of here when they left, but I did not. I could have even pressed charges. But that would not have helped me with finding Doris.”
“You know, I liked that remark you made of ‘in-laws’. I was almost ready to believe you when the police arrived. Now, tell me why is finding this Doris Batker is so important to you?” His voice was no longer one of authority; he had reached a personal level. “Are you in love with her?”
“I told you I was searching for Doris for the reward offered, but I did not tell you that this Tom Ashman will let me have a tidy sum if the girl is found. I must have every cent from both sources in order to try a little venture that I have in mind. Importation of certain optical glass.”
The Italian smiled in a friendly way. Offering me a glass of brandy, he said, “I am glad that you are not in love with this girl. That would complicate matters greatly. You see, those police would have loved to have gotten me to the station on any charge. They know that I am mixed up with white slavery, but they do not know how and they cannot prove a thing. But still, they would like to have a chance to question me. It stands to reason that if you had been from the police, as we first feared, we should have made that trip to the station.” He went on: “Einstein is a well known man not because he discovered anything new, but because he knew how to put Hamelton’s system of math before the scientific public. He used his head, not his strength. Suppose that you play Einstein for a week and let me be Hamelton. I will find the girl in the next seven days and report to you at your hotel. Register at the Bismark at my expense. Do not feel that was about the matter; white slavery is not my only income. And at heart I am an honest man.”
There was little to do but to follow his advice. He insisted that I should most likely be murdered if I were to try to find the girl without his help. Some other person might not believe my story.
My cab and driver were at the curb. “The police got here just in time. I phoned them before we came here. Always have them check me around here. Oh, I made some money at cards while you were being ‘questioned’.” I marveled at the insight of my driver, and I should like to have known how he got his keepers to play cards. And I wondered whether or the Italian, whose name I did not know, would be able to find the girl… or if he would try to find her at all. At that point it was interesting, but I was in no physical condition to honestly care.
By Saturday I had begun to care very much. When I thought that my month was a quarter gone and that I had nothing to show for it, save the promise of an unknown man, I began to feel uneasy. There had been no word from the Italian. He ha d said he would give results in a week, and the week would not be over until Monday; but my inactivity had made my fears of never having my import company grow to enormous sizes. I had made up my mind to go out for a drink when there was a light knock at the door. It was the Italian. Behind him stood my cab driver.
“I have good news for you. I had feared Doris to be dead. We generally do not use pictures of our girls while they work for us. Doris is alive and well. Anything else you wish to know of her you can ask her yourself. In the morning your old cab driver, whom you now see dressed as a chauffeur, will drive you to see Doris in my car.” The Italian was in a jovial mood. “Whenever I am looking for honest work, I shall expect you to give me a job.” He was out of sight before I could say a word to him.
“I wish I was smart like you and the Italian. He told me that he checked on you and found that you made better grades in college than he. Yes, sir, he is a Harvard man. He told me to be by for you at six in the morning. Good night.”
I had expected a short ride, but three days later we came to a medium size town in central Texas. My driver told me that in the morning I was to visit the doctor. And the following morning I was driven to the office of a Dr. E. S. Lowe. Just before I entered the office my driver handed me a note which told me that Dr. Lowe’s wife is Doris Batker. I found that she is more than his wife; she was his good right arm, in the form of a skilled surgical nurse.
But there are some questions I am not able to answer even after these days at Dr. Lowe’s: Who the Italian was. How Doris came to be a nurse. And so on. But I have found out why Doris left. And her return will not be at all welcomed by your mother who offered the reward in the first place. For the past six years Doris has supressed evidence that will convict your mother for murder.
Notes on this story –
With just a couple of exceptions, I transcribed this story exactly as written by my father over 70 years ago. I would guess that this was written in 1949. It was a class assignment for which he earned a B+ with the notation that while the story was good, it could have been balanced better. Thanks to Janice Sing for including this with materials having to do with “Cousin Julius” sent earlier this year. I may have to toy with this story a bit after I’m clear with the Chemo.
Until then, have a Happy Christmas and a Merry New Year!
[1] Two notes on this paragraph: The word “gaol” used by the writer is another term for “jail”. For the other, this was an assignment. After the mention of “the Italian and his boys” the instructor left the words “Where from?” in red and off to the side.